Hello, I am a Witch and my Crush Wants me to Make a Love Potion!
Doumo, Suki na Hito ni Horegusuri wo Irai Sareta Majo desu.
TL;DRToo Long; Didn't Read
A cosy, slow-burn fantasy romance about a lonely witch and the knight she can't lie to.
- A hermit witch with a four-year crush is asked by that very knight to brew a love potion, so she stalls by sending him after rarer and rarer ingredients.
- Rose and Harij are adorable together and actually talk to each other, but it is very slow, light on real magic, and the love potion itself bothers some viewers.
Overall7/10
Story
The title gives away the setup, and it is a painful one. Rose is a witch who lives alone on an island in a lake and has had a crush on the royal knight Harij for four years. Then he turns up at her door and asks her to brew a love potion.
Instead of refusing, she buys time. Every time he brings back an ingredient, she needs another one, just as rare. So he keeps coming back, with bread, with news from town and with questions she can’t dodge, because in this world a witch cannot tell a lie. Who the potion is really for comes out early, and it changes how the whole setup reads.
It is based on a light novel by Eiko Mutsuhana, and the anime spends all 12 episodes on a single volume, so nothing feels rushed. The series composition is by Wataru Watari, the author of My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU, which shows in the dialogue.
Pacing
Slow and deliberate, by design. Much of the early run takes place inside Rose’s tiny house, and while most viewers find that cosy, a few find it suffocating. Anyone who enjoyed Secrets of the Silent Witch will feel at home here; anyone who wants a romance to move along quickly will be tested. What it doesn’t do is pad its runtime with misunderstandings, which already sets it apart from most of its genre.
Characters


Rose


Hariju Azumu


Billaura


Tien

Rose Haha

Geones
Rose is anxious, awkward and has barely spoken to anyone in years, and plenty of viewers say they have rarely seen that kind of shyness portrayed so accurately. Harij is her opposite, steady, warm and unusually attentive, the kind of lead who remembers a flavour she mentioned once. Their banter carries the show, and both of them come across as green flags rather than walking tropes.
The main criticism is that he does most of the work. Some viewers feel Rose gets “fixed” by a perfect man instead of changing on her own, and the story does slip into a rescuer dynamic at times. Tien, the merchant who sells her remedies, brings welcome comic energy, and Princess Billaura is refreshingly sweet instead of the usual spoiled royal.
Art & Animation
diomedéa’s production is gentle rather than flashy. The backgrounds are pretty, with an art director whose credits include Monogatari and Madoka Magica, and the small facial expressions get real care, as do the chibi moments. Some episodes lean on still frames, but in a show this quiet it rarely matters.
Sound
Openings
- OP1Kanawanai, (かなわない、)by Centimillimental (センチミリメンタル)
Endings
- ED1Mada Uso ni Naranai (まだ嘘にならない)by Reini (レイニ)
centimillimental, known for Given, performs the opening “Kanawanai,”, and Reini sings the ending “Mada Uso ni Naranai”, both soft, pretty songs that viewers often name among the show’s best parts. The soundtrack is calm and fits the mood without drawing attention to itself. Mikako Komatsu gives Rose’s nervous rambling a lot of charm, and Youhei Azakami keeps Harij calm and warm, with Hiro Shimono as Tien.
Enjoyment
A low-stress, comforting watch, best enjoyed at the end of a long day. Despite the soft look, it does touch on bullying, prejudice against witches and one darker moment involving poison. A few viewers also can’t get past the love potion itself, since its whole purpose is to force someone’s feelings, whatever the reason behind it. And for a show about a witch, there is surprisingly little magic: Rose mostly mixes ingredients, more apothecary than sorceress.
Conclusion
A sweet slow burn with two likeable leads. Fans of cosy fantasy romance should give it a try. Anyone who needs things to happen quickly, or who can’t get past the love potion, will struggle.
